Unstoppable eyeliner pencil from maybelline

This review is my honest opinion which can be different with other people opinion. 

Maybelline is a nice brand.agree? Yes !  
I love maybelline because the price is 

good so do the products.
I use their mascara , blushon , BB cream and now I bought an eyeliner .
This is my first eyeliner from maybelline and so sorry to say , it's dissapointing. 

I bought this eyeliner pencil for my waterline and As an eyeliner for the waterline , from 1-5 , 0 . 
for the eyelid? 1.5 , (+) pigmented , (-) smudge , (-)easily fading or we can say that it really doesn't last long. =D

The reason I decided to buy this eyeliner is because maybelline claims this eyeliner are stayput, smudge-proof and waterproof,  But it definitely is not. Tet-tot

The fact, This "water-proof" eyeliner doesn't even stay on my eyes, and the "smudge-proof" ?? This eyeliner smudges like crazy and the Staying 

power is bad . 

At first, I confused, is it just me? By the way, FYI I'm not alone who feel that this product is terrible . Yes, I've read few nice comments about this product, but just few.

So what's good? 
The packaging is good .

I don't recommend this product. 

With <3 

Beautybliss